Skip to content
Christchurch Miami
Leer en español →

Holidays

A Christmas Parable

December leaves preachers scrambling for something new to say about Christmas. Here's a parable about a father, his children, and their presents — a mirror for how we actually receive God's gifts.

Jeff Reed Wednesday, December 17, 2025 3 min read
A Christmas Parable

December is crunch time for preachers. Have some sympathy for us, will you? How would you like to try to think of something new and fresh to say about Christmas?

As I was scratching my head, wondering what I could possibly offer that hasn’t been said a million times before, I stumbled upon this little-known fragment from the Dead Sea scrolls. It’s almost unbelievable how contemporary it feels. What do you think?


*Yea verily, saith the Preacher. There was a certain man who had a lot of children. On Christmas morning he left presents for each of them underneath the tree, and then found he a hiding place where, unbeknownst to them, he could watch them open their presents.

His shallow child picked up her present, and instead of opening it, just sat on the floor holding it and saying over and over, “Ooh, shiny … look at the pretty wrapping paper!”

His critical child took his in his hands and said, “Mine’s not wrapped very well. The edges are all crooked, the tape is very sloppy, and the bow does not match the paper at all.”



His materialistic child said, “I certainly hope Daddy spent more on me this year than he did last year.”



His vain child said, “Oh, I hope it’s a coupon for another trip to the cosmetic surgeon!”



His neurotic child said, “Oh no! I didn’t get him anything in return!”



His militant child said, “I cannot believe my father succumbed in this way to the crass, materialistic manipulation of our greedy, consumer-driven society.”



His analytical child said, “Giving us these presents must address some heretofore unmet need and/or unresolved conflict from Father’s own childhood, just as Freud suspected …” and would have continued on in this manner, but, yea verily, several of the other children stuffed their bows in his mouth.



His skeptical child said, “A present, huh? I wonder what the catch is.”


And his cynical child said, “Ha! What a bunch of suckers you all are. I’m sure

there’s absolutely nothing in these boxes at all. And about them coming from

this ‘Father’ figure – I have my doubts about that, too. Do you see him

anywhere around here?”

But his youngest child found her present, picked it up, and without even

opening it, made careful search until she found her father where he was

hiding. “Oh Daddy,” she said, “Thank you so much for remembering to give

me a gift this Christmas.”

“Don’t you want to open it before you say, `Thank you’?” said the father. “You

might not like what I got you.”

“No, Daddy,” she replied. “It doesn’t matter what you got me. I’m just grateful

to be your child.” And lo, the two of them hugged and had a wonderful

Christmas morning.

The rest of the little wretches he kicked out into the street and said, “Get a

job, brats! In fact, go get a bunch of jobs, you ungrateful little snots …”

Not really. He didn’t really kick them out. In fact, he still loved all of them,

even though they often did act like ungrateful little wretches.

But he enjoyed spending time with his youngest child more. And verily, canst

thou blameth him?*

Eerie, isn’t it? I guess there really isn’t anything new under the sun.

Have a wonderful, blessed – and grateful – Christmas and New Year’s.

Pastor Kent

Frequently asked questions

What is Pastor Kent Keller's Christmas parable about?
Pastor Kent Keller's Christmas parable is a tongue-in-cheek piece written as a 'little-known fragment from the Dead Sea scrolls' — a fictional ancient text that turns out to be startlingly contemporary. In the story, a father leaves Christmas presents for each of his many children and hides to watch them open the gifts. Each child reacts according to a different character flaw: the shallow child fixates on the wrapping paper, the critical child complains about sloppy tape, the materialistic child hopes Dad spent more than last year, the militant child rants about consumerism, the analytical child psychoanalyzes the father, the skeptical child looks for a catch, and the cynical child denies the father even exists. Only the youngest child sets aside her unopened present, searches out the father in his hiding place, and thanks him simply for remembering her — saying it doesn't matter what's in the box because she's just grateful to be his child. The parable is a gentle, humorous mirror held up to how we often receive God's gifts at Christmas — and a call to grateful, childlike trust.
What is the spiritual lesson of the youngest child in the Christmas parable?
The youngest child models the heart posture God invites in every believer: gratitude rooted in relationship, not in the gift itself. She picks up her present without opening it, searches out her father where he's hiding, and says, 'Thank you so much for remembering to give me a gift this Christmas.' When her father asks if she wants to open it first — she might not like what he got her — she answers, 'No, Daddy. It doesn't matter what you got me. I'm just grateful to be your child.' The lesson is that the relationship is the gift. Christmas isn't ultimately about what's under the tree; it's about a Father who remembered us, came near to us, and gave us His Son. Childlike trust says thank you before unwrapping, because the love of the Giver matters more than the contents of the package. Pastor Kent closes with a wish for a 'blessed — and grateful — Christmas and New Year's.'
Why do preachers say December is 'crunch time'?
Pastor Kent opens the parable by joking that 'December is crunch time for preachers' and asks for some sympathy. The pressure is real: every year a pastor has to find something fresh to say about a story the congregation has heard a thousand times. The Christmas narrative is fixed — Mary, Joseph, the manger, the shepherds, the wise men — and the temptation to either repeat the same sermon or strain for novelty is constant. Kent's solution in this post is to step sideways and tell a parable instead of a straight exposition. By framing the message as a fictional ancient fragment, he gets to mirror our modern Christmas attitudes back to us without sounding preachy. The humor is part of the point — congregations are more likely to receive a hard truth (that we're often ungrateful little wretches) when it's wrapped in a smile. It's also a gentle reminder to the church to extend grace to its preachers in the busy season.
JR

Jeff Reed

Pastoral writing from the team at Christchurch Miami — a faith family on mission in Kendall, Miami.