What About? (Week 11)
What About Manhood? · Group Guide
1 Samuel 17
Icebreaker
Think of something you have been putting off — a phone call, a repair, a conversation you know you owe someone. What finally moves you to do a thing like that, or is it still sitting there?
Discussion Questions
- 1
James found three men in this chapter — a giant, a king, and a shepherd. Goliath used his strength for himself; Saul, the biggest man in Israel with the most battlefield experience, heard the taunt and did nothing. Which of those two failures do you see more of where you live and work?
- 2
David's own brother Eliab accused him of a proud heart and evil motives, and David simply turned away and kept going. James said not every battle deserves your attention. How do you tell an Eliab fight from a Goliath one?
- 3
James kept repeating one line: strength surrendered to God for his glory and the good of others. Set the word masculinity aside for a minute — what would that look like applied to whatever strength you actually have?
- 4
James said we all want to be David, but we are much more like Israel — afraid, unable to save ourselves, standing behind the battle line until a champion steps out. What changes in this story when you read yourself as Israel instead of David?
- 5
Dr. Dorsett sat down with James after he had failed an exam and told him not to quit, and James says he wonders whether he would still be in ministry without that one conversation. Who has done something like that for you? Do they know it?
- 6
James asked, what is your giant? He said most giants do not live in valleys — they live in homes, marriages, habits, fears, and excuses. Name yours out loud. What is one step toward it you could take before next Sunday, and who here will ask you about it?
Subscribe to the podcast
Every Sunday sermon, in whatever app you already use.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.