Did Jesus Really Rise From the Dead? The Evidence From 1 Corinthians 15

If you've started following Jesus recently, you've probably noticed that the closer you get to Him, the more honest you become about the questions that don't go away. What about anxiety? What about suffering? What about the success that was supposed to fill me up, and didn't? What about my purpose on this planet?

Those aren't Sunday-morning questions. They're the questions we ask at 2 AM in the hospital. In counseling sessions. On deployment. In silence. Certainly when we're in pain.

Pastor James Drake - lead pastor of Christchurch Miami, U.S. Army chaplain, and a 20-year ministry veteran in the PCA (Presbyterian Church in America) - made the case this past Sunday, preaching live from his deployment in the Middle East in camo: before we can answer any of those questions, we have to answer one first - what about the resurrection? Because if Jesus didn't rise from the dead, none of the other questions have good answers. But if He did, then the resurrection doesn't just change history. It changes today.

The refrain James came back to all morning: "If the tomb is empty, anything is possible." Not just spiritually possible. Personally possible. Relationally possible. Eternally possible. Here's what that means for a new Christian trying to take the next step.

The Foundation Paul Went Back To

Here's the passage James preached from:

"For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve."

- 1 Corinthians 15:3-5 (ESV)

Pay attention to what Paul reaches for when the church starts to wobble. Not philosophy. Not a pep talk. Four verbs: died, buried, raised, appeared. And he calls them "of first importance."

Paul wrote this letter around AD 53-55. Most scholars - including resurrection historian Gary Habermas and New Testament scholar N.T. Wright - trace this short creed to within three to five years of the resurrection itself. It's a confession the early church was reciting out loud while the eyewitnesses were still walking around. Christianity didn't slowly evolve into belief. It exploded into a Jerusalem full of people who could, in theory, fact-check it.

For a newer Christian, that's worth sitting with. Our faith isn't a collection of moral tips or a vague sense that God is somewhere in the background. It's a claim about something that either happened in time and space or didn't. Paul would rather you trust a real event than a comforting idea.

The Whole Bible Was Pointing Here

Paul says "in accordance with the Scriptures" - twice, on purpose, inside four verses. After Jesus rose, Luke 24:27 records Him walking with His disciples and explaining how every part of the Old Testament had been pointing to Him all along.

James spent time on one of the clearest examples: Genesis 22. Abraham is told to take his son - "your son, your only son Isaac, whom you love" - and offer him as a sacrifice. The journey takes three days. The location is Mount Moriah - the same ridge in Jerusalem where Solomon later built the temple (2 Chronicles 3:1), and where, two thousand years later, Jesus would be crucified just outside the city walls.

Notice the pattern. An only son. A beloved son. Carrying wood for the sacrifice up a hill in Jerusalem to be offered by his father. At the last second, God stops Abraham and provides a ram as a substitute.

That story doesn't just mention Jesus. It whispers His name. An only Son, beloved by His Father, carrying wood up a hill outside Jerusalem to be offered in our place - except this time, the Father doesn't stop the sacrifice. Because there is no substitute for the Substitute.

The cross was not Plan B. It was the plan all along. The resurrection isn't a surprise twist at the end of the Bible - it's the moment the whole book has been leaning toward.

The Evidence Paul Names

A lot of new Christians carry the quiet worry that their faith would collapse if they looked at the evidence too closely. The opposite is true. The closer you look, the more the resurrection holds. Four of the pieces James walked through on Sunday are worth pulling forward - and each is part of what Habermas calls the "minimal facts" approach to resurrection evidence: claims that nearly all scholars, including skeptics, accept as historical.

The witnesses nobody would have made up

All four Gospels name women as the first people at the empty tomb. In first-century Jewish courts, a woman's testimony was not admissible as legal evidence - full stop. If the early church had fabricated the resurrection, they would never have built the story around witnesses the culture already doubted.

As James said on Sunday: this doesn't read like something they invented. It reads like something they recorded.

The tomb was in a known location

Jesus was crucified publicly and buried in a named tomb belonging to Joseph of Arimathea - a member of the Sanhedrin, the Jewish ruling council. If the authorities wanted to end the Christian movement on day one, all they needed to do was produce a body. They never did.

Every other major world religion has a grave you can visit. Christianity does not - because He's not there.

The burial cloths weren't thrown aside - they were folded

When Peter and John reached the tomb, John 20 records that the linen cloths were lying there, and the face cloth was folded up in a place by itself. James pressed the detail with his usual dry edge:

"Nobody steals a body and then folds the laundry. This is not theft. This is what victory looks like. The tomb does not look like a crime scene. It looks like a departure."

- Pastor James Drake

A robbery leaves a mess. What the disciples found was an empty tomb and order - one of the reasons John writes in verse 8 that when he walked in and saw it, he believed.

Over five hundred eyewitnesses

Paul doesn't shy away from naming numbers:

"Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep."

- 1 Corinthians 15:6 (ESV)

Paul is writing to people who could, in theory, travel to those witnesses and cross-examine them. He's not asking you to take his word for it - he's naming a verifiable crowd and saying go ask them. You don't invite fact-checking on that scale unless the story holds.

Two Lives That Only Make Sense If the Tomb Is Empty

The most compelling argument for the resurrection isn't a debate. It's two biographies.

James - the skeptical half-brother

Mary and Joseph had other children after Jesus, and one of them was named James. During Jesus's earthly ministry, James did not believe his brother was the Son of God (John 7:5).

Then Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 15:7 that after the resurrection, Jesus "appeared to James." One line. But the life that follows is unmistakable. James becomes a leader of the Jerusalem church, writes a letter still in your Bible, and the first-century historian Josephus records that James was executed by stoning around AD 62 for the faith he once dismissed.

What changes a skeptical brother into a church leader willing to die for what he once doubted? A resurrection. Nothing less does it.

Paul - the persecutor

Paul writes about himself with shocking honesty in verses 8-10. He was hunting Christians before he met the risen Jesus. He approved of their executions. And then:

"But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me was not in vain."

- 1 Corinthians 15:10 (ESV)

James framed grace like this on Sunday:

"You don't clean up your life and then come to God. You come to God and then he begins to clean you up from the inside out."

- Pastor James Drake

If you're newer in faith, hear that directly: the resurrection is not a test you have to pass before God accepts you. It's the announcement that He already has. Paul's past stayed on the page - he didn't edit it out - and grace sat next to it. You're allowed to do the same.

Legal scholars like J. Warner Wallace (Cold-Case Christianity) have long argued that the two hardest historical facts to explain away are the empty tomb and the conversion of Paul. You don't go from killing Christians to dying as one unless something happened on the road to Damascus you could not unsee.

What the Empty Tomb Does This Week

A lot of us try to take "next steps in faith" while still carrying old weights. The resurrection is the specific news that reaches into the places we tend to compartmentalize.

Your anxiety isn't erased, but it is re-framed: if the grave couldn't hold Jesus, nothing this week is outside His reach. Your past doesn't have to follow you forever - Paul's resume as a persecutor is preserved in the Bible right alongside his grace line, and you're allowed to let both be true. Your future has a real ending, and it's good. Christianity is forward-leaning because of the resurrection.

James framed it around the one refrain that carried the whole sermon: "If the tomb is empty, anything is possible." That's not a slogan - it's a load-bearing wall. As he put it in closing: your life can be made new - not because we try harder, but because He is alive.

Taking Your Next Step

The question Paul put to the Corinthians, and James put in front of us this Sunday, is the same one sitting in front of you this week: what are you going to do with an empty tomb?

If you're newer in faith, three concrete next steps:

1. Read the passage slowly, in one sitting. Open 1 Corinthians 15:1-11 and let the creed sink in before you read anything else today. It's a short read.
2. Pick one area - anxiety, past, or future - where you need the resurrection to be true this week. Name it out loud in prayer. Tell God where you need the empty tomb to land.
3. Don't carry this alone. One of the reasons we exist as a faith family at Christchurch is so new Christians don't have to figure this out solo. A community group, a conversation with a pastor, or a Sunday morning at 11 AM is the way faith grows - in company, not in isolation.

Christchurch Miami is a faith family on mission - Community · Grace · Purpose. If you're new to following Jesus and want a next step, we'd love to help you find one. Find a community group at christchurchmiami.org/groups, or join us in person Sundays at 11 AM, 8485 SW 112th St, Miami, FL 33156.

Common Questions About the Resurrection

Watch the Full Sermon